It was not my best reading year ever, but I still found some gems to pass along, a few duds, and several books that fell somewhere in between.
MY TOP FIVE
(*Jump to the bottom for a few more of my non-book favorites.)
#5: Hidden Christmas: The Surprising Truth Behind the Birth of Christ by Timothy Keller. This little book could be read in half a day, but I wouldn't recommend that. It's one you want to savor and ponder. Keller breaks down the Bible passages that we associate with Christmas and helps us take in the awe of what they mean. He also weaves in some of the very best Christmas-carol lyrics. If the story of the nativity feels too familiar to you, check out this little gem of a book, especially at Christmastime when you've heard Luke 2 so many times you've lost all perspective.
#4: Irreversible Damage: The Transgender Craze Seducing Our Daughters by Abigail Shrier. The author is an Oxford- and Yale-educated reporter for the Wall Street Journal. She came to this project not as an evangelical Christian like we might expect (she's not one), but as a reporter trying to solve a mystery. While Shrier supports gay and transgendered adults, she has serious questions about why so many teen girls, many as young as 13 and 14, have become the fastest growing group of transgendered individuals in the western world. Why are so many of them suddenly requesting (and receiving) artificial hormones and "top surgery" when gender dysphoria has historically been confined to a very small percentage of mostly males? Shrier talked to psychologists, doctors, parents, and the girls themselves, most notably to girls who later regretted their decision to transition into males. The author asks how many 20-something women will have to wake up one day to the nightmare that they've changed their voices, mutilated their bodies, and rendered themselves irreversibly infertile--with the consent of their parents and encouragement of the medical community--before we rethink on-demand gender reassignment? If this is an issue you care about, this book is not to be missed.
#3: Until Unity by Francis Chan. This book came with a lot of buzz when it was released earlier this year. Unity in the church is an important topic right now, and Chan is just the guy to box us in the ears and tell us to start obeying God's Word or else. He presents unity among God's people as an absolute biblical mandate; I've never seen it put so clearly and obviously. The book is short on application (no surprise, as Chan is more of a "Just do it!" guy than a "Let me teach you how" writer), and, unfortunately, is likely an exercise in preaching to the choir, as you wonder how many divisive-types are going to pick up this book. But for anyone who does, Until Unity is a loud, convicting call to the church to wake up, confess our pride, put our secondary doctrinal issues aside, and start practicing biblical love toward all believers, not just those we agree with.
#2: Knowing God by J.I. Packer. I'm a little embarrassed to admit that I'd never read this classic, which has been around as long as I have. But better late than never. I loved it. How can a chapter on the goodness of God be a page turner? How can it be that I was counting down the minutes of my day until I could crawl into bed at night and read about God's wrath? Packer, who died in July 2020, introduced me to new ways of thinking about God. He challenged me and put me in my place. I don't get to decide who I want God to be. "I am that I am" is who He is, and this 50-year-old book sends a clear message to a 2022 world that wants to shape God into whoever they want Him to be. Knowing God is as close as I'm ever going to get to systematic theology, but it was accessible, relevant, and even enthralling. I'll read it again, and my kids will all be getting copies at some point.
#1: All Things New: Heaven, Earth, and the Restoration of Everything You Love by John Eldredge. This is my "drop-what-you're-doing-and-read-this-book" find of the year. If you're not a fan of Eldredge, don't let that keep you away from this one. I've been on the fence about his writing for years. But I can say for certain that I loved this book. We need this book, all of us. We need this perspective, this hope. We need to live with eternity in mind. I much preferred All Things New to Randy Alcorn's Heaven and N.T. Wright's Surprised by Hope, at least partly because of Eldredge's whimsy and imagination. While those may have been the very things I haven't liked about him in the past, here I just buckled up and went with him, and I'm so glad I did. This is a book you'll be thinking about for months, and maybe, like me, rereading again very soon.
SOMEWHERE BETWEEN GOOD AND GREAT ( and in no particular order)
Peace Like a River by Leif Enger. I'd never heard of Enger, but a friend gave me this novel, and I enjoyed it a lot. First, because it's so hard to find fiction I can recommend with a clear conscience. This one I can. And second, because Enger's writing is breathtaking. This story drags in places, but the voice of the narrator--an 11-year-old asthmatic boy with a most unusual father and a brother on the lam--kept me reading each paragraph closely lest I miss some beauty of a sentence. The book is filled with them. The way the thoughts are expressed, the way the words are arranged, has moved Enger to the top of my future reading lists.
The Power of Place: Choosing Stability in a Rootless Age by Daniel Grothe. I was eager to read this book not only because I know the author, but because the topic hits a nerve with me. I had a parent who chose personal ambition over stability for our family, and I'm still learning how all those moves shaped the person I am today. Grothe argues against the ideas of wanderlust, conflict avoidance, single-minded upward mobility, and duty-free friendships that keep people from committing long term to one place. It's a countercultural proposition in a world that allows us to go anywhere, anytime, but Grothe makes a convincing case. Like Until Unity, I'm not sure that the audience that needs it most will ever find this book, but for me, it confirmed that the firmly-rooted life Kevin and I have chosen is not safe or dull, but a grand adventure in long-term investments and commitments.
Reading While Black: African American Biblical Interpretation as an Exercise in Hope by Esau McCaulley. I have much to learn from McCaulley, an excellent writer who earned his PhD in New Testament under N.T. Wright. This book, his second, was Christianity Today's book of the year, and McCaulley has been featured prominently in a wide spectrum of media this year. He wrote this book to black believers, and maybe some who were raised in the church but have let go of faith, about interpreting the Bible from an African-American context as an "exercise in hope." And it is hopeful. Though it wasn't written for me, I felt grateful to peek in on what McCaulley shared. He takes on questions like: What does the Bible have to say about a just society? Policing? Protest and rage? Ethnic identity? Slavery? None of these questions is easy and all have been debated before, but McCaulley handles them honestly, insightfully, and hopefully.
Hallelujah Banquet: How the End of What We Were Reveals What We Can Be by Eugene Peterson. This is everything you'd expect from a Eugene Peterson book, although he didn't actually write it. Rather, editors compiled it posthumously from a series of sermons he gave on Revelation 2-3. The letters to the seven churches have always scared the daylights out of me, so I appreciated the framing Peterson did for each church. Jesus was rebuking most of them, yes, but He was also encouraging them, loving them, and calling them to step up and be what He wanted them to be. The seven letters still have a message for us today, and this book helps us see more concretely just how relevant they are.
Talking to Strangers: What We Should Know about the People We Don't Know by Malcolm Gladwell. If I wrote books, I'd want them to be Malcolm Gladwell kinds of books. Has he ever written anything that wasn't completely fascinating? This book, released in 2019, centers on the encounter between Sandra Bland, a black woman, and the police officer who pulled her over for a lane-change violation in 2015. What ensued resulted in Bland being held in the county jail, where she hung herself. It didn't have to go that way, and Gladwell explains why that interaction went awry, while taking on the topics of Cuban spies, college frat parties, Ponzi schemes, and the greatest sexual abuses of our time. Somehow, as usual, Gladwell makes it all work and keeps you hanging on his every word.
Seculosity: How Career, Parenting, Technology, Food, Politics, and Romance Became Our New Religion and What to Do about It by David Zahl. So the subtitle pretty much sums it up. Zahl's argument is that we're all searching for something to answer the aching question inside us: Am I enough? While the gospel is the only real answer to that question, we search for enoughness in a variety of substitutes. Zahl is a clever writer, and I breezed through most of the chapters agreeing and chuckling. But his final two chapters, on politics and an unexpected entry on "The Seculosity of Jesusland," were particularly illuminating. He helped me better understand why the lines between political fervor and Christianity have become so blurred in our country. Also worth noting are the two quotes he uses at the beginning of the book:
"Half the harm that is done in this world is due to people who want to feel important. They don't mean to do harm--but the harm does not interest them. Or they do not see it, or they justify it because they are absorbed in the endless struggle to think well of themselves." (T.S. Eliot)
"The most purely, proudly American genre of writing might be the to-do list." (Parul Sehgal)
GOOD BOOKS THAT I CAN'T RECOMMEND
The Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self: Cultural Amnesia, Expressive Individualism, and the Road to Sexual Revolution by Carl R. Trueman. This book was as close to reading a textbook as anything I can remember since my college graduation. (Trueman is a Bible and theology professor at Grove City College.) Though it required deep reading that was often beyond me in the moment, I got the point. What feels crazy and sudden to us today--specifically, the cultural rule of the day to be whoever you want to be and identify as anything you'd like--has deep historical roots. Trueman got me all caught up on Rousseau, Nietzsche, Marx, and Freud, among many other philosophers I hadn't thought about since college, explaining how these thinkers from the 18th and 19th centuries drastically shaped our 21st-century cultural landscape. Though fascinating and educational, I don't recommend this one unless you're a serious enthusiast of history, philosophy, and culture.
Dominion: How the Christian Revolution Remade the World by Tom Holland (no, not that Tom Holland). This is my kind of book: detailed, well researched, well written, and on a topic that I care about immensely. But after starting it with vigor last January, I got stalled out in the Middle Ages around March, and I haven't touched it since. I include it here because I do intend to finish it. I might have to skim 300 pages and jump to the 20th century (which includes an intriguing chapter reference to a Beatles' song), but I would love to be able to cross this one off my list. Unless you are a serious reader with a passion for history, an uncanny ability to remember historical names, and a lot of time on your hands, I wouldn't recommend this one.
A WASTE OF TIME
Deacon King Kong: A Novel by James McBride. James McBride, I loved The Color of Water with all my heart. And I wanted to love this novel of yours. Especially because I only read two novels this year, which is so disappointing. But though this book was on all the must-read lists of 2020, I did not like it. Granted, I wasn't the target audience. It's hard for me to wrap my brain around devoted Christians who cheat on their spouses, drink their lives away, and swear like sailors. It's a stretch for me to understand life in the projects in 1970's New York. The story is fairly interesting--on the first page, a drunk church deacon shoots the biggest drug dealer on the block, a kid he used to coach in baseball--and the writing is amusing at times, but with a slew of side stories and characters I lost track of, along with drug and mafia themes I didn't quite get, I had to work to finish this one.
Untamed by Glennon Doyle. Though this was another New York Times bestseller, I couldn't stand it. Doyle is a great writer: insightful, transparent, hilarious. But she's also confused. Starting out as a Christian writer with a husband and three kids (she's still known today as a "Christian blogger"), she left her marriage in 2016 for a female sports celebrity. In Untamed, she tries to combine those two worlds with a lot of nonsense about being a cheetah. I read the book because I wanted to know what she did with God in the midst of her dramatic life change. I didn't need to read far to find out that she decided to craft Him in her own image. A third of the way in, I checked out.
*Other favorites that I recommend:
The Rise and Fall of Mars Hill podcast, a riveting 12-episode series produced by Christianity Today. I don't usually listen to podcasts, but I devoured this one. Even if you have a sketchy knowledge of Mars Hill and little interest in Mark Driscoll, this is a fascinating account of the American church over the past 25 years.
And speaking of Christianity Today, I'm an annual subscriber and cover-to-cover monthly reader. It's hard to know who to trust in the murky waters we live in today, but I trust and learn from CT. The addition of Russell Moore, another of my favorites, to the CT staff has made it even better.